On the eve of the most important military operation in American history, a group of soldiers is tasked with going behind enemy lines to destroy a Nazi radio jammer tower so that the Allied invasion of Normandy will have air support. Their mission is as critical to D-Day’s success as any other part of the Operation Overlord offensive. If that jammer isn’t down by 6AM, a lot of people are going to die.
You might be wondering if you’ve blinked and woke up in November and I’ve moved on from spooky coverage, but don’t worry. 2018’s Overlord, streaming on Paramount+, gets plenty spooky, but it starts with a bang. Several of them, really.
When we meet these soldiers, they’re in a plane above the fleet on their way to Normandy. The opening scene is not as brutal as Saving Private Ryan, but it is no less unforgiving as the movie takes no time at all to remind you that war is hell. Gunfire and flak tear planes apart, brave young men are cut down before they get a chance to face the enemy. It is an extremely visceral first scene to the movie and it sets the tone for the rest of the film. Scattered in the chaos, the squad’s mission has just begun and it’s already in jeopardy. The first scenes here on the ground are fantastically composed; there is no question that this kind of violence is sudden, it is vicious, and it is irrevocable. The night sky is black as space itself, the only light is coming from fires, giving it a hazy orange glow that feels like they’ve crash landed into a hell on Earth. If we’re following the hero’s journey, this is when our protagonists enter the underworld and have to find their way out. But not all of them do and even the ones we only get to know for a short time have an impact on you, which is a testament to the writing in this movie. Though there are some rough lines here and there, the characterization is spot on, largely because they rely on stock war movie characters and then give them individual charm, helped along by the list of underrated actors in this film.
The squad is led by Sergeant Rensin, the no-nonsense soldier who is unfazed by the war around him, played by Bokeem Woodbine (Fargo, Spider-Man: Homecoming), with the mysterious and single-minded Corporal Ford, played by possibly my favorite nepobaby Wyatt Russell (Lodge 49, Thunderbolts*), and Private Boyce, the shaky handed, gentle one that is presented as if he were wearing a red shirt on an away mission from the USS Enterprise, played by the perennially underutilized Jovan Adepo (Jack Ryan, 3 Body Problem). The squad is rounded out by the pigeonholed John Magaro (Past Lives, First Cow), playing the wise-cracking sniper Private Tibbet, the very much not combat ready photographer Private Chase, played by Iain De Caestecker (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.), and Private Dawson, played by Jacob Anderson (Game of Thrones). Lastly, there’s the petrified Private, played by Dominic Applewhite (The In-Betweeners), who is rightfully afraid of what the Nazis would do to a Jewish soldier like him, considering they were in the middle of committing a genocide against the Jewish people.
As you can imagine, with the squad making it to the ground the way they did, not all of them make it to the rendezvous, but those who do carry forward to complete their mission. Along the way, they stumble upon French villager Chloe, played in wonderfully expressive fashion by French actress Mathilde Ollivier (1899, Mrs. Davis), who sees bunch of men in uniforms carrying guns and makes a run for it. It’s not that she doesn’t know that they’re Americans and not Nazis; it’s just that when you know the brutality of war, it doesn’t matter the colors the men with guns wear, because wherever they go, violence follows. Ford orders them to capture her so she doesn’t give them up to the Nazis. This is where we start to see the divide between Ford and Boyce. Ford’s only concern is the mission. The math is simple for him. Everything is a trolley problem and the stakes of not flipping the switch in time are pretty high. Thousands of Allied lives landing at the beachhead in just a few hours, the lives in the occupied nations across Europe should D-Day fail, the lives of the Jewish people in concentration camps; nothing standing in their way could possibly come close to that kind of cost. So to Ford, there is no line he won’t cross to accomplish his mission. Boyce doesn’t do the math. He sees a life in danger and he wants to protect it. Timid though he may be, he’s unwavering in his view of right and wrong.
Fortunately, Chloe lives in Ciel Blanc, the town where the radio tower is located, so they go to her home to use it as a forward operating base while they figure out an approach. She lives with her 8 year old brother and her ailing aunt. We learn that the church where the radio tower is located is also the site of very strange goings-on. Boyce gets a look at Chloe’s aunt and what he sees is grotesque and only borderline human. Villagers live in great fear of being taken to the church because the ones who do come back do not come back the same. At Chloe’s home, we are introduced to Nazi Captain Wafner, a monster in every sense of the word. He’s played with a quiet and menacing demeanor by Pilou Asbaek (Game of Thrones), who is such an immediately hate-worthy character but who manages to avoid being a campy, over-the-top villain. His type of evil is very grounded in reality. When Chloe isn’t receptive to his advances, he is more than happy to threaten to take her brother to the church. When the sexual assault is imminent, Boyce breaks rank and intervenes. This is an important moment in everyone’s characterization. Boyce won’t let it happen, that’s why he’s the one you immediately empathize with; that’s part of his character, he wants to right wrongs or prevent them from happening. He may not be typically heroic when you first meet him, wouldn’t hurt a mouse and all that, but when he sees a wrong being committed that he can make right, he doesn’t hesitate. And with Ford, we see that to him the math is still simple; even though it’s happening right in front of him and is one of the worst violations of a person. But when Boyce makes his move, Ford immediately backs his play. There is tension in squad, they squabble, and Tibbet especially picks on the people he sees as weak in an effort to be tough (he won’t even have a catch with Chloe’s brother Paul), but when it comes down to it, these men are fiercely loyal to each other and they know right from wrong and they’re in France to do right. As much as Ford is willing to push up to the line, he has ones he will not cross. And they will be tested in this film. And Chloe, we learn, has been enduring this for long enough that she feels like she’s losing herself by what she’s having to survive. It’s a great setup for some payback for her.
They discover that the tower is also home to a horrific, grotesque laboratory where the Nazis are conducting inhuman experiments. I’m talking way beyond the realm of science and into science fiction here, with truly disturbing results. About halfway through the film, the horror elements are on full display after foreshadowing and hint-dropping. I don’t want to go into details and spoil anything for you, but if you’re thinking at this point that they made Call of Duty: Zombies the movie, you’d be so wrong. What looks like a low budget action-horror blend is hiding so much depth in its 1 hour, 50 minute runtime.
What makes this movie work is how seriously it takes itself. Sometimes this can be a negative when a movie takes itself too seriously and doesn’t deliver, but that’s not a problem here. Instead of calling out genre tropes and trying to get meta about it, they simply play the tropes and execute them well. Playing it straight down the middle like this really helps sell the blended fiction of the world. It’s not that far off reality, if you think about it, which makes the transition from war movie to horror movie so seamless. Hitler and the Nazis did all sorts of experiments, so it’s not too much of a leap to the fiction here of these lab-made monsters. You don’t expect a movie like this to feel realistic, but it does. It’s a really good example of historical science fiction and the horror aspects of the movie, even though you have to wait for them to really show themselves, are played very well. You’re thrilled when you’re supposed to be thrilled, you’re concerned when you’re supposed to be concerned, and you’re scared when you’re supposed to be scared.
This is another movie where a simple premise is elevated by fantastic character work. I can see why Wyatt Russell got the role of US Agent in the MCU after this. He carries himself well as a soldier, even though I will always think of him as slacker surfer Dud from Lodge 49. I can’t see why Jovan Adepo isn’t a bigger star, he is stellar here and in Jack Ryan. Well, I can make a few guesses, but I’ll leave that for another day. I’d also love to see more of Mathilde Ollivier, her commitment to the role here is fantastic and she’s believable from start to finish. John Magaro’s accent may leave him typecast, but I’ve never seen him in anything where he isn’t terrific. His performance in Past Lives especially shows off his talent, when he can still stand out in a movie designed to sideline his character (if you’ve never seen Past Lives, I highly recommend it; Greta Lee deserved an Oscar). Every main character has such a satisfying arc. Boyce’s kindness gives way to bravery replacing his timidity, Ford’s single-mindedness gives way to selflessness and true leadership that doesn’t come from his relative rank, but, rather, his innate ability to inspire. Tibbet finds that a tough exterior is less important than Boyce’s kindness. Chloe is able to find herself again. And they’re all likable, even though they’re flawed, because they’re all so thoroughly human and when push comes to shove, they are all willing to sacrifice everything to do what’s right. And that meant stopping the Nazis no matter the cost to themselves. Because Nazis have to be stopped. Always.
I don’t often talk about the technical aspects of a film because I’m not really qualified to talk too deeply about it, but there is something special about how this film was put together because I really noticed it watching this time. The visual composition, especially in the first act, is stunning. The aforementioned hellscape visuals from the opening few scenes have stood out in my mind since rewatching it. It’s perhaps not as disturbingly beautiful as the nighttime shots from 1917, but they’re of a kind. And then the sound engineering here is also noteworthy. When these people fire a gun, you can feel it. The pops of bass came through even on my HomePod Minis and really helped bring you into the action. When a gun is fired, you heard the report, you saw the bolt fly back and forth and heard it slam into place. There’s even a moment where you get foley of the famous M1 Garand ping that was all over Saving Private Ryan. And a large percentage of the special effects were practical and not CGI, which really makes for a great, visually consistent experience. You never get a moment where dodgy CGI takes you out of the immersion.
You probably know that horror isn’t really my genre, but the horror movies that really resonate with me are often allegories for grief. Titles like The Babadook or The Outsider explore the grieving process so humanly, they give you a worthy emotional payoff for the dread you and the characters experienced. Overlord though, is much more straightforward. It’s about the seemingly simple concept of right and wrong, good and evil. Being simple isn’t bad; it’s like on Top Chef, you can win with a simple dish as long as every part of it is executed well. And that’s Overlord. The tension and urgency permeate every frame. It is breathless and panicked and you always feel the deadline they’re up against. Even in the few calm moments of the film, the weight of the mission hangs heavily in the air. Time is running out and it has been since they were still on the plane. When they make the final push to take the tower, they have an hour left to complete the mission or D-Day will be a disaster. If I have an hour to get ready and meet someone for a drink, I’m probably going to be late because invariably I’ll pick up my phone and get distracted or think to myself “Yeah, yeah, I have time for a little Pokemon ZA”. These guys have to infiltrate a Nazi facility, plant explosives, and, if there’s enough time, get the hell out of there and to minimum safe distance so they’re not buried along with the jamming equipment. And also, it’s a horrible laboratory that has monsters in it. Call them zombies if you want, but whatever they are, you can trust they’re going to complicate things. Five versus forty—at least forty (living) Nazis—and monsters to boot. It’s a desperate, uphill battle and one which they cannot lose.
The odds of survival are long and they are willing to make them worse to save as many innocent lives as they can. The right thing is stopping the Nazis and they’re willing to die to do it. Even if it means going against monsters, because, really, when people act as monstrous as the Nazis, what is the difference between human and monster anyway? The movie even points out that the Nazis went out of their way to put the jammer tower in a church, perverting religion for the furtherance of fascist authoritarianism. Anything that is meant to be good is tainted by that kind of evil. And Overlord is about people who stand up and stand against it. And because of how successfully this hidden gem blends war, action, and horror, it’s a film that you can slot into your movie night whether you’re in a spooky mood or you want to see some stuff get blown up. Every time I watch this movie, I’m always surprised at just how good it is when it very easily could have been cheesy and silly. But this low budget film pulls off the horrors of war and the horrors of the fantastic at the same time so well, it’s hard to believe that JJ Abrams was involved. Apparently they had flirted with the idea of tying this into the Cloverfield universe, but thank goodness that idea fell through. As a standalone movie, Overlord sets an example for what lower budget films should look like and what Hollywood should be doing more. Overlord cost a reported $38 million to make. The Electric State cost $320 million. Over eight times the budget and where did it go? Like Upgrade or Attack the Block, Overlord is a great example of what filmmakers, writers, directors, and actors can do with a limited budget, a good script, and the dedication of everyone involved. It’s not to be missed.